What a video game must have to succeed

  • A clear value proposition, accessible gameplay, and depth that appeals to diverse profiles.
  • An active community before launch, professional validation, and a scalable roadmap that brings the game to life.
  • Applied UX and psychology: ease of use, autonomy, attention, and memory at the service of design.
  • Fair balance and progression, with a business model that doesn't disrupt the competitive experience.

What a video game must have to succeed

Launching a game that truly resonates with the audience is much more than code and flashy graphics: behind it there is Strategy, player-centered design, and early signs of traction that are worth knowing how to detect. If you're in the midst of development and wondering if you're on the right path, here you'll find a very comprehensive and actionable overview.

The industry is no small thing: in Spain it generated 2.339 billion euros in 2023 (AEVI), and by 2018 it had already easily surpassed film and music with 1.530 billion. The audience is massive and diverse; in fact, 16,8 million people They played in Spain in 2018, with an average age of 36 and a habit of playing around five hours a week. In this context, it's time to specify what a video game must have to literally succeed.

A clear proposal: the “elevator pitch” that will win everyone over

The first sign that you are doing well is that you can explain your game in a single sentence that highlights your unique value. It might be a novel mechanic, a bold aesthetic, or a compelling narrative, but it must be crisp. Trying to cover everything often dilutes the project's personality, while titles that stand out They define their hook very well and sustain it in every design decision.

Think of this as your consistency filter: if an idea doesn't reinforce that hook, it's out. Less dispersion, more identityAnd yes, test it out loud: if the person listening to you catches it right away, you're onto something.

Real interest before launch: community and validation

Another powerful sign is that there is organic expectation before you go out. People who ask for dates, share progress, join Discord, or answer surveys: all of that is gold. Not only does it increase your visibility; it also gives you first-rate feedback. polish the product in time.

Furthermore, the fact that publishers, investors, or professionals are interested without you chasing them is an indicator of market value. When someone wants to bet on you, it's because they perceive commercial potential and design consistencyAt this point, it's worth looking at examples that emerged from training environments and took off, such as the horror game The Occultist from the Valladolid studio DALOAR Studios (formerly Pentakill Studios), or the case of Frostfire, a fighting game that emerged from the EVAD ecosystem thanks to the support of former master's students.

Engaging gameplay and well-balanced accessibility

The average player wants a challenge, but also feel progress without hitting a wallA balanced design combines depth for those who want to master the system with a gentle learning curve for beginners. If you try it with different profiles and everyone enjoys it, it's a green balance flag.

The ultimate test is called retention: if your testers are asking for "one more," you're close to something special. That "I can't put the controller down" isn't a coincidence; it's the result of fine-tuned gameplay loops and timely rewards that feed intrinsic motivation.

To structure the design from its core, the MDA approach (Mechanics, Dynamics and Aesthetics) is clarifying: mechanics define what the player does, dynamics emerge from their interaction with the system and aesthetics encompass the emotions you awakenIf you align the three layers, you elevate the experience.

Key elements of video game design

Psychology applied to UX: ease of use, autonomy and memory

The goal of video games is to entertain, and to achieve this, it's important not to fight with the human brain. Veronica Zammitto (EA) summarizes several musts: usability (clear controls and goals), autonomy (offering meaningful choices), competence (improving with practice), and socialization (connecting with others). If you incorporate these pillars, satisfaction soars.

“Replayability” is also key: ensuring that the title maintains variety even after many plays. This is achieved by games that allow different roles, varied builds or emerging situations that are renewed in each session. Keeping the challenge fresh extends the life of the project.

UX expert Celia Hodent reminds us that perception is subjective, attention is scarce, and memory fails. The moral of the story: make sure the player perceive what is important when it touches, avoid communicating critical things during moments of high cognitive load and refresh what you did last time when returning to the game after several days. Fortnite exemplifies the idea with a "recipe" of objectives upon entering, centering the user without friction.

When you translate this to your interface and onboarding: don't overload, guide with clear signals and distribute the information. And if you want engagement, open up avenues for personal expression and collaboration (see Minecraft or the cooperative modes that complement the competition).

Progression, balance and business model

Your progression system should avoid repetition and promote feeling of constant progressThink about difficulty scaling, meaningful unlocks, short- and long-term goals, and a flow that keeps the player in their ideal challenge zone.

Be careful with balance: if the game is unbalanced, the perception of unfairness ruins everything. And with micropayments, doubly dangerousIf you pay to win, the experience suffers; opt for cosmetic content or expansions that don't break fair play. Balancing internal economies is part of the design, not a last-minute fix.

Plan a route map At least for the first year: reasonable updates, events, quality of life improvements, and scalable avenues (modes, stories, or collaborations). Scalability is one of the great traits of games that sustain themselves over time, whether through DLC, seasons, or evolving to become a franchise.

Genres and trends that attract audiences

Competitiveness is a magnet. As Alberto Sastre (Deusto Formación) points out, the biggest draw is usually competition: from shooters with ratings to titles with a scene. e-sports that drive audiences and streaming sponsorship. Designing for competition requires precision in balance, clarity of objectives, and matchmaking systems that respect the player's level.

On PC, MMORPGs remain strong because of their ability to create persistent worlds and communities that They gain loyalty through events and social progressOn mobile, idle games are successful because they allow you to progress without spending too much time; often are monetized with ads which also offer advantages to the user for keep the loop attractive.

From concept to shipping: fundamentals and stages

Before you open the engine, understand why your idea works. Work out rules, goals, rewards, and boundaries. The MDA model, again, will force you to align mechanics, dynamics and aesthetics with the type of excitement you're chasing. Learning to detect what makes a system addictive and how to scale it without breaking it is a superpower.

Typical stages of development: 1) Idea and differentiating concept2) Structure: levels, characters, objects, and progression system. 3) Programming: rapid prototyping, iteration, and stability. 4) Art and sound: visuals and audio are not decoration, they count the game5) QA: Intensive testing, difficulty adjustments, and bug fixes. 6) Launch and distribution: Platforms, stores, and a community ready to welcome you.

From the training field, there are itineraries designed to make the professional leap: programs of Video Game Programming and Design, 2D Art and 3D Animation taught by teams with real production experience help shorten the learning curve, practice with guided projects and create a network of contacts useful for publishers and studios.

Indie Route: Visibility, Retention, and Time Control

Being indie is wonderful, but the competition is fierce. The first thing is the visibility: Differentiate yourself from the same approach, communicate well, and regularly reach your niche. Copying for the sake of copying rarely works: if people want Mario, they play Mario.

Taking a formula and modernizing it can be a good idea: Candy Crush didn't invent match 3, but it knew how to adapt it to mobile, polish accessibility and monetize wiselyThat's the key: offering something familiar with a relevant twist for your audience.

Retention comes with expanding content: new levels in puzzles, narrative chapters In RPGs, events, or weekly challenges in competitive play. From level design to story, everything counts to make the player feel like their time is worth it.

In costs and deadlines: try to make sure that your first project does not extend more than one or two yearsWithout a track record, it's difficult to attract investment, so it's worth building experience (and small successes) to support your next step. Like any trade, you also learn here by working with others before setting up your own studio.

Art, credibility and originality: your voice as a designer

Sherida Halatoe emphasizes that the games that mark propose experiences that only you could create. There's no need to pursue photographic realism; just make the world believable in its own right. Experiment with artistic styles, be bold with tone, and let your vision permeates every detail.

Originality isn't a trophy, it's a practice. If something has already been done the same way, it may not be worth repeating. Instead, a personal approach—a perspective, a mechanics, a sensibility—can transform a familiar concept into something fresh.

Playable characters and emotions

Characters are the vehicle of the plot, not the plot itself. Make sure emotions are conveyed. through gameplay: decisions that hurt, risks that matter, rewards that resonate. If you can make the player feel with the character, you've hit the nail on the head.

Don't get hung up on labels like "this isn't a video game"; experience is what mattersIf your proposal excites, the format will find its place.

Work habits and equipment care

What a video game must have to succeed

Development isn't a sprint. Step away from the computer when it's time, sleep well And don't beat yourself up for comparing yourself to others. Ask yourself why you make games and remember that failure is part of the process.

Take care of the legal basics: get advice on intellectual property, contracts, and user data. And separate, where possible, your identity of the project outcomeThis helps you iterate with a cool head and make healthy decisions.

Gameplay as a science: modeling and evaluating the experience

From the University of Granada, José Luis González Sánchez and Francisco Luis Gutiérrez Vela led a line of research that defines the gameplay as the set of properties that describe the player's experience with a game system, with a clear objective: to entertain in a satisfactory and credible way, alone or in company.

Gameplay, they explain, integrates functional features (typical of any interactive system) and non-functional features (the experiences the player gains). Based on educational tools and classroom video games developed in previous projects, their work advanced in formalize and standardize criteria for evaluating video games.

They started from the essentials - what a video game is, what parts it is made up of and how they relate - to "model" them and have a theoretical framework of analysis that allows for the study of any aspect of the medium. Already in 2009, they demonstrated the economic weight of the sector in Spain, with figures above those of music and film, according to ADESE.

Notable team publications: Padilla Zea, González Sánchez, Gutiérrez, Cabrera and Paderewski, "Design of Educational Multiplayer Videogames. A Vision from Collaborative Learning" (Advances in Engineering Software, Elsevier, 2009, Doi:10.1016/j.advensoft.2009.01.023); and the chapters “Playability: How to Identify the Player Experience in a Video Game” (INTERACT-2009, LNCS 5726, Springer) and “From Usability to Playability: Introduction to the Player-Centred Video Games Development Process” (HCII-2009, LNCS 4739, Springer). They are key references if you are interested in the intersection of HCI and game design.

Researcher contact: José Luis González Sánchez, Department of Computer Languages ​​and Systems (UGR). Tel: 626 578 988Email: ugres (string obfuscated at source). If you work with sensitive data, always consult your university or legal counsel.

Market data and how to use it to your advantage

Spain is the third largest market in the EU (after Germany and France). Physical and digital sales are increasing, and communities are growing, fueled by streaming and events. For you, this translates into two levers: find the genre where your proposal shines and design for the real audience that consumes that content (not a supposed one).

Expert statements highlight that time-based scaling systems, visual appearance and balance are essential for avoid the feeling of repetition and abandonment. A credible, public roadmap that explains the game's future strengthens confidence and helps align expectations.

Training, mentors and ecosystem

Passion drives, but training guides. Environments like EVAD Formación focus on programs with a practical focus on Programming and Design, 2D Art and 3D Animation, with teachers who have passed through royal productionsThis mentoring shortens learning times, exposes you to industry challenges, and expands your network.

There are also university degrees focused on Video Game Creation and Storytelling with up-to-date facilities and specialized teaching teams. The key is to combine a theoretical foundation (design, MDA, narrative, UX) with end-to-end projects. The more guided practice, the better your portfolio will arrive.

Frequently asked questions that are helpful to be clear about: 1) How long does it take? It depends on your ambition, but it can range from months to years. 2) Do you need programming skills? There are engines that allow you to get started without advanced knowledge, although understand logic It adds up a lot. 3) Career opportunities? Programming, level design, art, animation, audio, production, and QA, among others.

Press releases and industry analyses sometimes include the tagline “information provided by the company,” a useful sign to recognize context and approach from each source. Always compare and prioritize data from associations like AEVI and academic publications when planning your strategy.

If we put it all together, the picture becomes clear: a video game that has a chance of success usually presents unique proposal, an active community even in pre-release, accessible yet deep gameplay, progression that avoids monotony, a firm balance, well-understood psychology and UX, scalability with a roadmap, and a solid design foundation supported by training and user testing. Add your own artistic vision, good work habits, and sensitivity to the business model, and you'll be much closer to making your game not only popular, but to stay.

Person in front of laptop with word MOOC on screen
Related article:
Best MOOCs to learn how to create video games